1. Home
  2. Knowledge & Tips
  3. TM52 Overheating Assessments for Offices: The Three Criteria and What Has to Pass

TM52 Overheating Assessments for Offices: The Three Criteria and What Has to Pass

CIBSE TM52 tests a naturally ventilated or free-running office against three criteria, using a dynamic thermal model. Criterion 1 limits the hours the room is 1 K or more above its adaptive comfort limit to 3% of occupied hours between May and September. Criterion 2 limits how severe one day can be (a daily weighted exceedance of no more than 6). Criterion 3 caps the room at 4 K above the comfort limit. A room that fails any two of the three is classed as overheating. No Building Regulation asks for a TM52 assessment of an office: it is called for by planning policy (in London, for every major development), by BREEAM Hea 04, or by the client's brief.

Talk to an engineer or call 0114 312 1105

This article covers new offices in England and the 2013 edition of TM52. Schools use a modified version of the same test, set out in BB101, and homes use TM59. The three TM52 criteria apply to rooms without mechanical cooling; air-conditioned offices are assessed differently, as explained below.

Who asks for a TM52 assessment

Where it comes fromWhat it asks for an officeWeather file
Building Regulations Part ONothing. Approved Document O applies to new residential buildings onlyNot applicable
Building Regulations Part L (volume 2)A solar gain check on each occupied or cooled space, reported in the BRUKL. This isn't an overheating assessmentSet by the compliance software
London Plan Policy SI 4 (major developments)Dynamic overheating modelling to TM52 at planning stage, plus the cooling hierarchyDSY1 for the 2020s, high emissions, 50th percentile, with further tests using DSY2 and DSY3
BREEAM Hea 04For naturally ventilated buildings, the design limits overheating risk using the TM52 adaptive method. A second credit repeats the test for a future climate2020s for mechanically ventilated spaces, 2050s for naturally ventilated spaces
Client or funder's briefWhatever the brief says, often "TM52" with no edition or weather file namedConfirm in writing

Outside London, a council may ask for an overheating assessment through a local plan policy or a planning condition. The wording varies from one council to the next, so read the condition before the model is built.

What Part L checks, and why it isn't enough

Approved Document L volume 2 (2021 edition, paragraphs 4.17 and 4.18) limits solar gain in every occupied or mechanically cooled space of a non-domestic building, air-conditioned or not. The gain through the glazing, added up from April to September, must be no greater than it would be through a reference glazing system. For a side-lit room, that reference is east-facing glazing 1 m high across the full width of the room, with a g-value of 0.48.

This check looks at solar gain only. It takes no account of occupancy, equipment, ventilation or thermal mass, and it says nothing about the temperature the room reaches. An office can pass the Part L solar gain check and still fail TM52.

The three criteria

TM52 uses the adaptive comfort method from BS EN 15251. The temperature people find acceptable in a free-running building rises and falls with the weather outside, so the limit moves with it:

  • The comfort temperature is Tcomf = 0.33 Trm + 18.8, where Trm is the running mean of the outdoor air temperature.
  • The maximum acceptable temperature adds the range for the comfort category. For Category II (normal expectation, used for new buildings), the range is 3 K, so Tmax = 0.33 Trm + 21.8.
  • ΔT is the room's operative temperature minus Tmax, rounded to the nearest whole degree.
CriterionWhat it measuresLimit
1. Hours of exceedanceOccupied hours with ΔT of 1 K or more, May to SeptemberNo more than 3% of occupied hours
2. Daily weighted exceedanceHours above Tmax on one day, each weighted by how many degrees aboveNo more than 6 on any one day
3. Upper limit temperatureThe highest ΔT at any occupied timeΔT must not exceed 4 K

A room that fails any two of the three criteria is classed as overheating. A room can fail one criterion and still pass the assessment, but the failed criterion should be reported and looked at.

What the limits mean in practice

Criterion 1 depends on the hours your office is occupied. As an illustration, an office occupied from 09:00 to 18:00 on weekdays has roughly 980 occupied hours between 1 May and 30 September, so the 3% limit is about 29 hours. A different occupancy pattern gives a different number of hours, which is why the model needs your real hours.

Criterion 2 is reached quickly. Two hours at 1 K over the limit and two hours at 2 K over, on the same day, give a weighted exceedance of 6: (2 × 1) + (2 × 2). One more warm hour that day fails the criterion.

Criterion 3 is about the peak. At ΔT above 4 K, opening windows and adjusting clothing no longer restore comfort, and most occupants will say the room is too hot.

Comfort categories

CategoryExpectationRange above Tcomf
IHigh. Also for very sensitive or fragile occupants2 K
IINormal. The default for new buildings3 K
IIIModerate4 K

Source: BS EN 15251 categories, as reproduced in BB101 Table 7.9.

Weather files

The weather file decides the result as much as the design does, so it should be agreed before the model is run.

  • DSY1 is a moderately warm summer, and it is the file the criteria are normally expected to pass.
  • DSY2 is based on 2003, a year with a very intense single warm spell.
  • DSY3 is based on 1976, a year with a prolonged period of sustained warmth.

For London, the GLA's Energy Assessment Guidance (June 2022) expects the criteria to be met with DSY1 for the 2020s (high emissions, 50th percentile), and asks for further tests with DSY2 and DSY3. It accepts that passing with DSY2 and DSY3 is difficult, but where a room fails, the applicant must show that the risk has been reduced as far as practical and that passive measures, including less glazing and more external shading, have been explored. London has three weather locations to allow for the urban heat island, and the one most representative of the site should be used.

For BREEAM, the knowledge base (KBCN0842) says New Construction projects use 2020s files for mechanically ventilated spaces and 2050s files for naturally ventilated spaces, at the 50th percentile.

Air-conditioned and mixed-mode offices

The three criteria were written for buildings in free-running mode: no mechanical cooling, with occupants able to adapt. They don't apply to a fully air-conditioned office, where the cooling plant holds the room at a set point and the question is whether the plant is sized correctly.

  • BREEAM Hea 04 assesses air-conditioned buildings against the operative temperature ranges in CIBSE Guide A Table 1.5, or the Category B limits for PMV and PPD in ISO 7730. Naturally ventilated buildings use TM52.
  • Mixed-mode buildings are assessed space by space. BREEAM expects naturally ventilated spaces to meet the naturally ventilated criteria and air-conditioned spaces to meet the air-conditioned criteria.
  • In London, the GLA also expects the cooling demand of each cooled non-residential space to be below that of the Part L notional building, using the figures in the BRUKL report. If it can't be, the energy statement must explain why.

Cooling doesn't remove the need for a model. Under the London Plan's cooling hierarchy, active cooling comes after passive measures, so the planning submission still has to show what shading, glazing and ventilation were tested first.

Usual reasons an office fails

  • Large areas of unshaded glazing facing east, south or west.
  • Deep-plan floors ventilated from one side only.
  • Window openings restricted for security, noise or air quality, so the modelled free area is much smaller than the window size suggests.
  • No secure way to ventilate at night, so the structure never cools down.
  • Lightweight construction, or thermal mass hidden behind suspended ceilings and raised floors.
  • Occupancy and equipment gains higher than the model assumed, particularly in meeting rooms.
  • A model run with a different weather file from the one the planning authority or assessor expects.

Before the model: a checklist

  1. Confirm who is asking for the assessment: the planning authority, the BREEAM assessor, or the client.
  2. Confirm the weather files in writing, including any future climate files.
  3. Confirm which spaces are naturally ventilated, mixed-mode or air-conditioned.
  4. Get the occupied hours and occupant numbers for each space type.
  5. Get the lighting and small power gains, including meeting rooms and any server or comms rooms.
  6. Get window types, opening angles, restrictors and the free areas they give.
  7. Get the glazing specification (g-value and U-value) and details of any external shading or blinds.
  8. Agree whether night ventilation is allowed, and how it would be secured.
  9. Model every occupied space, and report all three criteria for each.
  10. Report any failures with the mitigation options tested.

More on the service: CIBSE TM52 overheating assessments and BREEAM Hea 04 thermal comfort.

Questions

FAQs

Is a TM52 assessment a Building Regulations requirement for offices?

No. Approved Document O applies to new residential buildings only, and Approved Document L asks for a solar gain check, not an overheating assessment. TM52 is asked for by planning policy, BREEAM Hea 04 or the client's brief.

Does an office have to pass all three TM52 criteria?

No. A room is classed as overheating if it fails any two of the three. A room that fails one still passes, although the failed criterion should be reported and the cause looked at.

Does TM52 apply to air-conditioned offices?

The three criteria apply to free-running spaces without mechanical cooling. Air-conditioned spaces are assessed against fixed comfort ranges or PMV and PPD limits. In a mixed-mode building, each space is assessed by the method that matches how it is cooled.

What is the difference between TM52 and TM59?

TM59 is the method for homes. It takes TM52's first criterion, adds a night-time test for bedrooms, and fixes the occupancy and gains so every assessment uses the same assumptions. TM52 covers non-domestic buildings and uses the building's own occupied hours.

Test the design before the facade is fixed

Send us the plans, sections, elevations, the window and glazing specification, and the planning condition or BREEAM requirement you need to meet. We'll model every occupied space in IES VE, report all three criteria against the agreed weather files, and test shading, glazing and ventilation options where a room fails. Fee proposal within one working day.

Talk to an engineer

Accredited by

CIBSE Low Carbon Energy AssessorCIBSE Low Carbon ConsultantElmhurst Energy Approved

Get in touch

Send drawings, fee proposal within 1 working day.

Office address
Spaces Acero, 1 Concourse Way, Sheffield, S1 2BJ
How we use your details